AuthorRiley, A.M. & Prior, G.
Year2003
TitleBritish and Irish Pug Moths - a guide to their identification
ISBN0 946589 51 8
TypeBook/Report
How CompleteAll the British species known at the time
Source264pp, Harley Books
Illustrations12 colour plates of adults (three times!), over 300 figures and 49 vice county maps
Review (by Malcolm Storey)

At 71 taxa (52 spp) the pugs are our largest single group of closely related macrolepidoptera. A number of species are common and the group will be familiar to anybody who has run a light trap. But many of these small moths are closely similar so careful attention to detail is required and "detail" is precisely what this book provides.

After a short introduction, the text begins with "How to use this book" which includes checklists and a formalised identification procedure. This is a useful feature for a group of macro-moths which cannot be reliably identified from photographs alone. Historical review of the species and Breeding and rearing pugs follow.

The main body of the book is Description of the British and Irish pug species . Each entry comprises history, imago (characteristic features, genitalia, variation), similar species (unusually this looks complete, with descriptions of the crucial differences of up to thirteen similar taxa), ovum, larva – including foodplants and instars, pupa, flight period and habitat, distribution, collecting (ie obtaining early stages) and rearing.

Next comes Genitalia with drawings of male valva where distinctive, aedeagus and female bursa copulatrix. [Alternative drawings which some people find easier to use are found in Geometridae of Euope, Vol 4 (Tony Davis pers comm)] There follows drawings of the male abdominal plates which are diagnostic and offer a stepping stone to full genitalia preparation for the field entomologist. Illustrations of the larvae follow, drawn from the dorsal aspect, in half tone as the colour is said to be variable and misleading. Vice-county distribution maps presents 49 dot maps using frequency-related symbols.

The Colour Plates, which follow the main text, include David Wilson’s photographs of set specimens. These are to his usual high standard, familiar from Bernard Skinner’s Colour Identification Guide to Moths of the British Isles. (In case you’re wondering, these are new photographs of different specimens!) Most taxa actually appear three times: life-sized photographs of set specimens in taxonomic order (3 plates), followed by the same photographs rearranged into groups of similar taxa (5 plates) and finally live moths in natural pose and setting (4 plates). My only criticism of the book is that the photographs of these small moths are only life-size; if the photographs of the set specimens are to be presented twice, surely one set could have been enlarged?

The book concludes with three Appendices: Glossary, Table of Phenology (all stages) and Foodplants and associated larvae (uptodate list, including garden plants, with sources), then References and bibliography (21 pages) and taxonomic index.

Examine Stereo Microscope
Specimen PreparationGenitalia preps often needed, although males can be identified from abdominal plates
Identification difficultyPugs are never easy, and some people find the genitalia drawings take a little getting used to.

Notes & PurposeStatusTaxonEnglishClassification
For identificationCurrentLARENTIINAEa subfamily of geometrid mothsAnimalia: Lepidoptera: Geometridae
Creative Commons License
This website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International Licence.

Unless otherwise expressly stated, all original material on the BioInfo website by Malcolm Storey is licensed under the above Creative Commons Licence.

BioInfo - Wildlife Information (UK)